458 West 23rd Street
Co-opLandmark1 Active Sale

Fitzroy Brownstone

458 West 23rd Street·Chelsea · Manhattan · NY · 10011
13
Units
5
Stories
1900
Built

Photos

Overview

Fitzroy Brownstone, at 458 West 23rd Street, is a 5-story walk-up co-op building in Chelsea, Manhattan. Built in 1900, it has 13 units.

Available Now

1 unit
Price drop · 58 days ago

Unit 3A

$650,000

↓ $25K
1 Bed · 1 Bath · 600 SF
Listing courtesy of Corcoran Group

Building Details

TypeCo-op
EraPre-war
ClassC6 · Walk-Up Cooperative
Gross square feet6,135
Lot size2,173 SF
Lot dimensions22 × 98.8 ft
ZoningR7B
BIN1012715
BBL1007200076

Unit Mix

1 BR07 units
2 BR03 units

Building Policies

PetsNo

Transaction History

UnitDateStatusBRBASFPricePPSFRecords
3AMar 18, 2026Active11600$650,000$1,083
RLS20078009
1BFeb 4, 2025Closed11575$650,000$1,130
RLS11012199ACRIS
4A
BASEMENTR
GARDENRGF

See this building's full history

Sign in or create a free account to see all 13 sales, 4 rentals and building statistics.

Sign up to view full listing details

Location

458 West 23rd Street

Similar Buildings

Lloyd 19Courtesy of Elliman
Co-op

Lloyd 19

453 West 19th Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

12 unitsBuilt 2008

1 Active Sale

410 West 25th StreetCourtesy of Prime Manhattan Residential LLC
Co-op

410 West 25th Street

Chelsea, NY 10001

12 unitsBuilt 1985

No active listings

460 West 23rd StreetCourtesy of R New York
Co-op

460 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

11 unitsBuilt 1986

1 Active Sale

426 West 23rd StreetCourtesy of Weichert Properties
Co-op

426 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

10 unitsBuilt 1978

No active listings

405 West 21st Street
Co-op

405 West 21st Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

12 unitsBuilt 1976

No active listings

Fitzroy Place
Co-op

Fitzroy Place

430 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

10 unitsBuilt 2013

No active listings

456 West 23rd StreetCourtesy of The Agency Brokerage
Co-op

456 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

10 unitsBuilt 1987

No active listings

Highline 519Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Condo

Highline 519

519 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

11 unitsBuilt 2005

1 Active Sale

Chelsea Gardens Condominium
Condo

Chelsea Gardens Condominium

468 West 23rd Street

Chelsea, NY 10011

11 unitsBuilt 1986

No active listings

200 11 Avenue
Condo

200 11 Avenue

Chelsea, NY 10011

15 unitsBuilt 2007

No active listings

Interested in Fitzroy Brownstone?

Get in touch and we’ll answer any questions about availability, pricing, and the neighborhood.